Who are we?
We are a group of people who have previously been involved with The New Kadampa Tradition (NKT-IKBU) and/or have supported those in recovery from involvement. Some of us are named below as contributors or supporters, however many do not feel safe enough to be named due to The New Kadampa Tradition’s history of attacking critics and testimony writers.
Dr Michelle Haslam is a clinical psychologist with over 8 years experience of working with people with complex attachment related difficulties and addictions. She is also an ex-resident of Nagarjuna Kadampa Meditation Centre who began whistleblowing in March 2019. Her most popular video is ‘How I believe the New Kadampa Tradition hooks you in through your trauma and then retraumatises you’. Michelle’s workplaces now remain confidential after attacks from senior New Kadampa Tradition members via her workplace the day after her psychological analysis of the NKT went viral. Michelle now has a special interest in indoctrination, cultic dynamics and cultic abuse. She is a member of the International Cultic Studies Association.
Andrea Ballance is an ex-ordained member of the NKT who left in 2003. She has been very keen to warn people about the NKT and the damage they can inflict on people. She has published many videos and articles on hers and others experiences. Her YouTube channels are here and here.
Carol McQuire is an ex-ordained member of The New Kadampa Tradition. She was a member for 12 years and ordained for 9 years. Carol has been a New Kadampa survivor activist for several years. Carol has a degree in Social Anthropology from Cambridge University. You can watch Carol speak here. One of her writings on the NKT is here. Being one of the first to speak strongly about her experiences, Carol has received and continues to receive extensive harrassment, threats and bullying from senior NKT members.
Geoffrey Bonn is an ex-ordained member of the NKT. He writes at Leaving the Sangha. Due to ill health Geoffrey doesn’t get to write as much as he would like to. He recently wrote a piece on the trolling received by ex-members.
Tenzin Peljor was a member of The New Kadampa Tradition for 4 years. He was a teacher and was ordained. He remains a monk but does not practice within the NKT. Tenzin runs various websites that assist people in finding information on abuse in Buddhist groups: info Buddhism and the Buddhism Controversies blog. He is a member of the German Buddhist Monastic Association (DBO). You can watch Tenzin talk with Michelle about his experience of indoctrination here and about recruitment here. Tenzins written testimony is here. Tenzin has suffered extensive character assassination as a result of his work. The NKT were successful in banning him from editing their Wikipedia page due to the argument that he had too much trauma to be trusted.
Carmelo Russo is an ex-resident of Nagarjuna Kadampa Meditation Centre and a retired mental health nurse. Carmelo’s video testimony is here.
Christian Szurko is a spiritual abuse recovery specialist who has worked with many ex-members of high demand groups, including the NKT. He is director of DialogueCentreUK, offering information, understanding and help about high-demand religious or political groups and the effects of involvement with them. Christian mentored Michelle during her whistleblowing process. Christian is especially interested in educating people about the potential dangers of practicing meditation within a cultic environment. You can see Michelle talk to Christian about recovery here. Chris Shelton interviews Christian on his channel Sensibly Speaking. Christian talks to Chris about first steps in helping someone out of a destructive group.
Matthew O’Connell is an ex-resident of an NKT centre. He has produced several podcasts sharing his opinion on the NKT and Buddhist cultic groups in general. You can listen to Tenzin speak with Matthew O’Connell in an Imperfect Buddha episode here. Matthew interviews Michelle here.
Eddie Nuttall is a play and playwork specialist and consultant with over 25 years experience in the children’s workforce. He is the author of numerous publications on play and playwork, and runs a large adventure playground in the West of England where he lives with his family. Eddie lived in NKT centres in the north West for three years in the nineties, and experienced severe depression and anxiety in the years after leaving. He is particularly interested in accountability over mental health issues in the NKT, and greater rigour in the safeguarding of vulnerable people. Eddie’s video testimony is here: Part 1 and Part 2. You can watch Eddie speak about NKT sectarianism here.
Dr Yuval Laor received his PhD in culture studies from Tel Aviv University, where he was supervised by leading evolutionary biologist Eva Jablonka. His dissertation explored the evolution of religious psychology, with an emphasis on evolutionary accounts of the human capacity for fervor and sudden conversion, and his subsequent work has focused on the nature of fervor. Yuval has published articles in the Journals of Religion Brain and Behavior and History and Theory. He is currently working on a book entitled The Religious Ape: What cults and fervor can teach us about the evolution of religion. You can watch Yuval talk with Michelle about fervor in The New Kadampa Tradition here.
Jon Atack, ex-scientologist, author and speaker. Jon is generally acknowledged as the world’s leading authority on the history of Scientology. He has contributed to over 200 media pieces, many government investigations and over 150 court cases. His work has been acknowledged by over 40 academics. Jon recently started his own YouTube channel with his son Sam, helping educate people on coercive control. You can watch Jon speak about spotting cult warning signs here. Jon interviews Michelle and speaks about NKT attacks on survivors here.
Adrian Oertli, psychotherapist and former left extremist group member. Adrian is involved in promoting nonviolence and cult education in the protest/alternative movement. He was recently interviewed by a journalist for the most widely read daily Newspaper in Switzerland (20 minutes) for an article on Extinction Rebellion. He speaks about how critical voices are shutdown within activist movements.
- Steve Hassan, former member of the Moonies and author of ‘Combatting Mind Control’ and ‘The Cult of Trump’
- Dr Alexandra Stein, social psychologist, cult specialist and author of ‘Love, Terror and Brainwashing’
- Emily Francis, ex-member
- Andrew Cheadle, ex-resident of Nagarjuna KMC
- Richard Litchfield, ex-member
- Gabriella Markgraf, ex-member
- Linda Ciardiello, ex-resident
- Recy Kypri, ex-member who sadly died in January 2020
- David Suppan, writer on ethics in spiritual groups
- Many others who do not wish to be named at the present time for safety reasons
What are our aims?
We aim to provide multimedia informational materials to assist people in making informed decisions about their involvement with the NKT. Michelle has written them with the support and advice of other ex-members, some of whom are named as contributers and some remain anonymous.
‘Thanks to the internet, I can now have a sense of fellowship with others who had nearly identical experiences. It wasn’t “all in my mind” after all‘Anonymous testimony ‘My NKT Hell‘
There are currently no face-to-face support groups for ex-members of the NKT specifically. However there a two support groups for ex-members of cultic groups via Family Survival Trust in Manchester and London. For details please email email@example.com.
According to Anders (2019) ex-members of so called ‘Buddhist’ groups often report that they needed immediate help upon leaving. Please note that many survivors report suicidality shortly before or after leaving and are at risk of homelessness due to economic abuse and exploitation (Anders, 2019). If you are experiencing a crisis or are worried about someone who might be, please seek support from any family and friends outside the NKT, your local crisis team, visit A&E or call a hotline such as The Samaritans. Sadly, many mental health professionals do not understand how cultic groups operate, but speaking to an outsider may still help validate your perception and intuition.
Any abusive and traumatic experience that you have suffered is likely to be reframed as just ‘your karma’ in order to deflect from the abuser and to silence trauma (Anders, 2019). Social support is the biggest predictor of recovery from trauma, however ex-members are likely to believe they should be able to ‘transform’ suffering entirely cognitively instead of through social support and empathy.
Sadly we are unable to provide practical or emotional support for those leaving the NKT on an individual basis, for personal and professional reasons (apart from via DialogueCentreUK). The Recovery from the NKT team work hard to try and raise awareness of how the NKT operates in mental health professionals and social workers however this has proved very challenging and has had limited success.
How can you help?
If you would like to submit a piece of writing on the NKT or be named as a supporter please email Michelle at firstname.lastname@example.org.
June 2019: Eighteen hours after Michelle’s analysis of the NKT went viral senior NKT emailed her workplace using a fake identity in an attempt to trigger her, threaten her and her workplace, and character assassinate her as mentally ill (a cult classic). See video by Andrea Ballance for an example of how survivors felt about this attack.
July 2019: Former members around the world were appalled and angered by the defamation website set up to attempt to destroy Michelle. The journalistic style reveals the fake psychologist to be the same perpetrators as ‘Indy Hack’. This timing prior to summer festival suggests the main purpose of the defamation website was information control for the purpose of reducing the cognitive dissonance of current members regarding Michelle’s report. Righteous anger led several former members to write about this online: ‘A Buddhist perspective on Buddhist Trolling‘; ‘Defame and Destroy‘; ‘UK Psychologist being harrassed by Buddhist cult‘ and ‘Please let me warn you about the NKT‘.
November 2019: Research has now been published on the silencing of trauma and abuse in so-called Buddhist groups (Anders, 2019a, 2019b). Initial recommendations for therapeutic approaches for former members have been made. This research has now been quoted throughout this website. The defamation website against Michelle has now been reworded to change the language used around Michelle’s mental health following her video calling out the archaic pathologising language. The perpetrators have also now included Michelle’s father’s mental health problems as further evidence of her PTSD being ‘minimally’ related to her experiences with the NKT.
December 2019: The Religious Trauma Institute are offering free workshops and resources on recovery. You can register to watch their workshop on religious trauma and the nervous system. Matthew O’Connell interviews Michelle about her NKT experience in an Imperfect Buddha podcast episode. Jon Atack, ex-scientologist and author chats with Michelle on his YouTube channel.
January 2020: Several survivors are horrified and worried to discover that Gen-La Thubten (Neil Elliot) is due to teach in a hotel in Carlisle in February on ‘Living without stress’. This breaks the NKT’s internal rules, which state that an ordained person who breaks their vows should not teach again. Thubten is widely known to have had sex with many of his followers under the guise of spiritual practice. After sending a complaint to Manjushri regarding Gen-La Thubten teaching again a survivor has received a suspicious email on January 13th. The email falsely used the identity of a fellow survivor and sent a suspicious link. Several survivors have now complained to the hotel but with no success. (Please also note that it is not possible to ‘Live without stress’).
Dr Michelle Haslam released an updated version of her full analysis of the NKT. For those who already read an old version, additions include: deception via hidden name; obscuring the sectarianism from newcomers; ‘Be very careful not to give the impression it is a recruitment drive; encouraging teachers to be inauthentic; analysis of trolling; quotes from testimonies, and more cultic studies literature. Look out for potential smear campaign updates on http://www.dr-michelle-haslam.com.
Jon Atack interviews Michelle on recruitment and waking up from The NKT. Chris Shelton interviews Christian Szurko, spiritual abuse recovery specialist (and Michelle’s mentor) on his channel Sensibly Speaking. Christian talks about first steps in helping someone out of a destructive group.
Jon Atack and Michelle discuss recovery from authoritarian groups and prevention. Be Scofield, cult reporter releases an article on the NKT which details abuse and attacks on survivors – the first of its kind. Five days after the release of this article, the NKT senior management have now ‘parked’ the defamation website against Michelle, proving that it was them and they are panicking about their reputation being ruined.
A current member was blocked from the Students and followers of Kelsang Gyatso FB page after asking what happened to the young NKT teacher called Gomchen.
Lauren, an ex-member from Australia began making her own YouTube videos ‘I think I was in a cult’ Part 1 and Part 2. Lauren tells more of her story of recruitment and how she experienced anxiety and dissociation that was spiritualized and ignored by NKT teachers.
Former Scientologist Chris Shelton interviews Michelle on his channel Sensibly Speaking.
Dr Michelle Haslam appears on BBC One The Big Questions debate show to discuss ‘Does mindfulness cause more harm than good?’. This can be viewed on BBC iPlayer or via this YouTube video.
The Religious Trauma Institute are offering free workshops live on Facebook on covid-19 and it’s relationship to religious trauma. Is social distancing reminding you of the isolation you felt in your religious community/sect?
NKT members have been posting on the students and followers of Kelsang Gyatso Facebook page requesting teachings be made free during Covid-19. These comments were deleted by admins (information control and discussion control).